Many readers and authors find magic systems in literature to be fascinating. From the wand-waving spells of Harry Potter to the subtle allure of "American Gods" by Neil Gaiman, magic may take various forms in literature. Yet, hard magic and soft magic have arisen as two seemingly separate, distinct techniques. This post will examine the differences between the two and present examples of each, as well as the grey area between the two.
Hard Magic System
Hard magic systems contain apparent constraints and rules. Often, these systems and their laws are discussed in considerable depth, with a focus on how the magic works. A hard magic system necessitates that characters learn and practice certain methods in order to effectively use magic. This approach is often associated with high fantasy and science or craft fiction, in which magic is treated as a kind of science that can be studied and understood.
Examples of hard magic systems include:
Brandon Sanderson's Mistborn series, where magic is powered by ingesting metals and is governed by a clear set of rules and limitations. This gives rise to the possibility of conflict and creativity for characters in overcoming their limitations while staying inside the established laws.
Patrick Rothfuss's Kingkiller Chronicle, where magic is taught in a university setting and requires a deep understanding of the underlying principles.
Somewhere in the Middle: Harry Potter's Magic System
J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter books' magic system is often mentioned as an example of a hard magic system, although, in my opinion, incorporating various aspects of soft magic. On the one hand, Harry Potter's magic is regulated by laws and constraints, and the series gives a thorough explanation of magic. To cast spells efficiently, specific incantations and wand motions must be learned and practised. It is impossible to resurrect the dead or manufacture food out of thin air. Nonetheless, there are certain perplexing and inexplicable aspects to Harry Potter's magic. Wandlore, for example, claims that some wands are better suited for particular forms of magic and that the wizard is chosen by the wand. There are also magical beings and objects that do not seem to obey any laws, like the Philosopher's Stone and the Sorting Hat. Also, it is not made completely clear what steps a wizard or witch has to go through to be considered more powerful. This is why I personally would define the magic system in Harry Potter as laying somewhere in the middle between hard and soft systems.
Soft Magic System
Soft magic systems, on the other hand, are more enigmatic and mystical in nature and feel much more mysterious to the reader. The rules and restrictions of magic are sometimes left unexplained or weakly specified. Magic is often associated with the natural world or supernatural, even divine powers, and its use may be unpredictable. This style is often connected with fairy tales and magical realism, in which the focus is on the wonder and mystery of magic rather than its mechanics.
Examples of soft magic systems include:
Neil Gaiman's Stardust, where magic is tied to the realm of Faerie and operates according to its own whims and rules.
Gabriel García Márquez's One Hundred Years of Solitude, where magical occurrences are part of everyday life and are not explained or analyzed.
Lord of the Rings, where the magical powers of Middle Earth work in mysterious ways and few clear rules about the powers of the individual magic-wielding characters are established
Ursula K. Le Guin's Earthsea series, where magic is tied to the power of words and names and operates in a more intuitive and organic manner.
Which System Is Right for You?
Deciding between a hard and soft magic system is a matter of personal choice and story needs. By establishing limits and consequences, a hard magic system might help you develop tension and drama in your story. A soft magic system, on the other hand, may provide a sense of surprise and unpredictability to your story while also allowing you to explore the enigmatic and incomprehensible aspects of magic. It is important to note, however, that the distinction between hard and soft magic systems is not always clear, and some systems may fall somewhere in the middle. Whichever approach you choose, it is vital that you adhere to your magic system and avoid breaking your own rules if you chose to establish them. Inconsistencies or discrepancies may interrupt the reader's immersion and undermine your world's believability. Finally, the option between a hard and soft magic system is determined by the demands of your narrative as well as your own tastes as a writer. Whether you prefer a precise and planned approach or something more mystical and surprising, both hard and soft magic systems have benefits and may be utilized to produce exciting and compelling stories.
Comments